In the world of private investigations, the adage "you get what you pay for" often holds true. When seeking the services of a private investigator (PI), you will most certainly come across a wide range of options, from cheap, budget-friendly investigators, making all sorts of unrealistic and wild promises, to more expensive, verified, and legitimate professionals.

Understanding the differences between these two ends of the spectrum can help you make a better-informed decision and is really very important. This blog, will explore and compare the two, and the various factors that distinguish a cheap private investigator from a more costly, but reliable, professional and legitimate private investigator.

Birmingham | London | Manchester

Qualifications and Experience

One of the primary differences between cheap and expensive private investigators lies in their qualifications and experience.

• Cheap Private Investigator: Typically, a cheaper Private Investigator may have minimal formal training or experience. They might be new to the profession or lack specialized skills. While they may be eager to take on cases, their lack of experience could lead to mistakes or oversights, which in turn, may cost you more, as repeat surveillance sessions or checks, may be required due to a compromise, or lack of evidence obtained.

• More Expensive, Verified Private Investigator: On the other hand, a verified and legitimate PI often comes with a wealth of experience, certifications and qualifications. They have likely undergone extensive training and have a track record of positive and successful cases. Their expertise allows them to handle complex situations with confidence and precision, which will often be reflected within their pricing structure. They will have a better understanding of exactly what is needed to give you the clarification and answers you need.

Certifications and Affiliations

Certifications and affiliations are crucial indicators of a private investigator's credibility.

• Cheap Private Investigator: In some instances, cheaper investigators might not hold the necessary qualifications and affiliations required. While here in the UK the industry is still unregulated, it is good and professional practice to hold certain industry qualifications and affiliates. This lack of credentialing can not only compromise the quality of the investigation but also put you at legal risk. If the cheap Private Investigator, with no limited company, nor any social media or Google maps listing wants to take your money and run, or produces below par footage and evidence, you’ll have little to no chance of getting a refund, or them being held accountable for their unprofessional actions, such is there lack of industry connections, affiliations and true identity.

• More Expensive, Verified Private Investigator: A more costly Private Investigator is usually fully certified, adhering to all the legal standards. They are more likely to be transparent with who they are, sharing their professional backgrounds on sites such as LinkedIn and other social media platforms. These credentials and platforms demonstrate their commitment to maintaining professional standards and ensuring their work is both ethical and legal. It also means that they may be held accountable for any wrongdoing that may be caused. In turn, also creating an element of trust and transparency.

Local | National | International

Access to Resources and Tools

The resources and tools available to a private investigator can significantly impact the effectiveness and quality of their work.

• Cheap Private Investigator: Budget investigators may not have access to the latest technology or extensive databases. They might rely on free or outdated resources, which can limit the scope and accuracy of their investigations. They will often work as a lone wolf, with zero connections to the industry, training providers and so on.

• More Expensive, Verified Private Investigator: Premium Private investigators invest in cutting-edge technology and subscribe to comprehensive systems and databases. These tools allow them to gather more detailed and accurate information, enhancing the quality of their investigations. If I told you how much money my “kit bag” was worth, you’d probably not believe me. The same can also be said for many of the costly databases that are used by Private investigators and tracing agents.

Attention to Detail and Thoroughness

An investigator's attention to detail and thoroughness can make a significant difference in the outcome of a case.

• Cheap Private Investigator: Due to constraints on time and resources, a cheaper investigator might rush through cases, potentially missing critical details. Their approach may be more cursory, focusing on quantity over quality. Again, there are certain things that Private investigators do, that can only be done through having industry training and experience. A cheap Private Investigator is unlikely to have any of that, and little to no knowledge of how to obtain evidence properly and professionally.

• More Expensive, Verified Private Investigator: A legitimate and more costly PI takes the time to meticulously analyse every aspect of a case. Their thoroughness ensures that no stone is left unturned, leading to more accurate and comprehensive findings. A more costly Private Investigator may recce and plan an investigation several days before. They may spend many hours or days meticulously planning for an investigation prior to it going ahead.

People Tracing | Background Checks | Surveillance

Professionalism and Ethical Standards

The level of professionalism and adherence to ethical standards can vary greatly between investigators.

• Cheap Private Investigator: Cost-cutting measures might lead cheaper investigators to engage in unethical practices, such as breaching privacy laws or using underhanded tactics. Such actions can jeopardize the integrity of the investigation and expose you to legal issues and complications.

• More Expensive, Verified Private Investigator: Reputable investigators adhere to strict ethical standards and operate within the bounds of the law. Their professional approach ensures that the investigation is conducted with integrity, safeguarding both their reputation and your interests.

Client Communication and Transparency

Effective communication and transparency are essential for a successful working relationship with a private investigator.

• Cheap Private Investigator: Budget Private investigators may not prioritize client communication, leading to sporadic updates and unclear reports. This lack of transparency can leave you in the dark about the progress and findings of the investigation. It’s not uncommon for these cheap Private investigators to paint a perfect picture, full of outlandish promises and guarantees, but once they have received payment from their clients, to then disappear, or become very distant and lack any sort of urgency and communication.

• More Expensive, Verified Private Investigator: A higher-priced Private investigator values clear and consistent communication. Often this may also be late at night or early hours of the morning. They provide regular updates and detailed reports, ensuring that you are fully informed at every stage of the investigation. Their transparency builds trust and fosters a collaborative and positive relationship.

Risk of Legal and Financial Consequences

Hiring a cheap private investigator can sometimes result in unforeseen legal and financial repercussions.

• Cheap Private Investigator: The use of unethical or illegal methods by a budget investigator can lead to legal complications and financial penalties for both the investigator and you, the client. Additionally, the likelihood of obtaining inadmissible evidence is higher, which will most certainly hinder your case.

• Expensive, Verified Private Investigator: A verified PI operates within legal boundaries, reducing the risk of legal repercussions. Their professional conduct and adherence to regulations help ensure that any evidence gathered is admissible in court, protecting you from potential complications.

Dedicated | Diligent | Discreet

Success Rates and Case Outcomes

The ultimate goal of hiring a private investigator is to achieve a positive and successful outcome for your case. The difference in success rates between cheap and expensive investigators can be significant. There also has to be a reasonable chance of a success. While a Private investigator can never guarantee what the outcome will be, we need to ensure that we have a reasonable chance of a positive and successful outcome. Sometimes client requirements are so far fetched, or unrealistic, we simply cannot assist. You may find a cheap Private investigator will take on such work, knowing that they can’t achieve the desired outcome for the client, but, don’t care, as long as they get paid! Phone hacking springs to mind. I talk to so many clients who have paid fraudulent and shady companies for a "phone hack", to be presented with absolutely nothing several days or weeks later. Firstly any sort of phone hacking is highly illegal here in the UK, and secondly, it simply cannot be done remotely. It's a common enquiry we get. I always clearly state the above, but sadly, there are often clients who have already fallen for this trap and lost large amounts of money! If it sounds too good to be true, it normally is!

• Cheap Private Investigator: Due to their lack of experience, resources, and thoroughness, cheaper investigators may have lower success rates. Their findings might be incomplete or inaccurate, leading to unsatisfactory case outcomes.

• More Expensive, Verified Private Investigator: With their extensive experience, advanced tools, and meticulous approach, verified investigators tend to have higher success rates. Their comprehensive and accurate findings contribute to more favourable and positive case outcomes.

Long-Term Benefits versus Short-Term Savings

While the cost of hiring a private investigator is an important consideration, it's crucial to weigh long-term benefits against short-term savings.

• Cheap Private Investigator: Opting for a budget investigator may save you money initially, but the potential drawbacks, such as incomplete investigations, legal risks, and unsatisfactory results, can outweigh these savings in the long run.

• More Expensive, Verified Private Investigator: Investing in a verified and legitimate PI might require a higher upfront cost, but the long-term benefits, including accurate findings, legal compliance, and successful case outcomes, often justify the expense. The peace of mind and quality of service provided by a reputable investigator can be invaluable.

Private | Legal | Commercial

Case Study: The Impact of Hiring a Cheap PI

Consider the hypothetical case of Sarah, who hired a cheap private investigator to look into suspicions of infidelity. The investigator, lacking experience and resources, conducted a superficial investigation. He failed to gather concrete evidence and used questionable methods, leading to inadmissible findings. Sarah ended up losing more money by hiring a second, more expensive but verified investigator to redo the investigation. The second PI's thorough and professional approach not only provided clear evidence but also ensured that the findings were legally sound.

Let's also talk about Hayley. She wanted to locate her biological father who she had never met. She chose to go with the first company she came across who were charging peanuts for the trace. She was handed a report, and was initially pleased with the outcome. Sadly, it quite quickly became obvious that the information was many years out of date. The "cheap company" she had hired, had merely copied and pasted information from a 192.com record, which was ten years out of date. Now, if she had rung around, she'd of had a better understanding of exactly how traces work, and how any professional investigator doesn't use such sites. It's also common for professional investigators to carry out discreet enquires, door knocks and further verification techniques, that take time and effort. If you are paying £30 for a trace, is the company going to carry out the above, with such a limited budget and therefore very little time allocated for the case? Probably not!

Conclusion

Choosing between a cheap private investigator and a more expensive, verified investigator involves more than just comparing costs. The differences in qualifications, experience, resources, professionalism, and ethical standards play a crucial role in the quality and success of the investigation.

While budget considerations are important, it's essential to evaluate the potential risks and benefits of each option. Investing in a verified and legitimate private investigator can provide peace of mind, accurate results, and long-term benefits that far outweigh the initial cost. When it comes to private investigations, the old saying often rings true: you get what you pay for!

My advice to anyone looking to engage in the services of a Private Investigator in the UK, is to ring around, please! Talk to different companies, get a feel for who you are talking to, ask questions, ask for samples of work and check them out online. Are they a limited company? Do they have a Google map listing? Do their reviews appear legitimate? Do they have industry affiliations? Discuss your budget and what you are prepared to spend. A professional and legitimate Private investigator may cost a little more, but they will always try to work within the budget set out, giving you different options to be considered, in order to obtain you the clarification, answers and evidence you need!

Leading | Established | Award Winning